Tax & retirement planning
The Roth Conversion Everyone Recommends — and the Tax Bill Nobody Mentions

By Tyler Lavoie

Earning income is something we all have to do. It's part of everyday life: eat, sleep, go to work, maybe squeeze in a workout, rinse and repeat. Then the promotions come, the paychecks get bigger, and somehow we're still asking, "Where is all this money going?"
For a lot of people who start earning serious income, the first suspect is good old Uncle Sam. So they call their CPA and ask, "How can I pay less in taxes?" Then they scroll online and run into thumbnails like "Tax Strategy: Roth Conversions — Make Your Tax-Deferred Money Tax-Free!"
Some of those videos are helpful. Others make it sound like everyone should be converting, and that if you don't, you're guaranteed to pay more in taxes later. That isn't always the case. A Roth conversion can be a great tool, but it comes with a few catch-22s, and the tax bill is often bigger than the headline makes it sound.
What a Roth Conversion Actually Is
A Roth conversion means moving money from a tax-deferred account, like a traditional IRA, into a Roth IRA. Qualified withdrawals from a Roth can later come out tax-free. The catch is that you pay income tax on whatever you convert, in the year you convert it.
There are two ways to cover that bill. Say you convert $100,000, you're in the 22% bracket, and the whole amount stays in that bracket:
- Pay the tax from the conversion. You have $22,000 withheld for taxes, so only $78,000 lands in the Roth. You still owe tax on the full $100,000, and that $22,000 isn't counted as converted. The IRS treats it as a withdrawal. If you're under 59½, it gets hit with a 10% early-withdrawal penalty, another $2,200, unless an exception applies.
- Pay the tax from savings. The full $100,000 goes into the Roth, and the $22,000 comes from your checking or brokerage account. This is usually the more efficient route, if you have the cash.
Either way, the converted amount gets added to your income for the year. Your income also drives a handful of other things in your financial life, and that's where people get surprised.
Your Tax Bracket Now vs. Later
This is the question the whole Roth conversion decision comes down to: is your tax rate today lower or higher than it will be when you take the money out? Think of it like buying gas. If you know prices are going up next month, you fill the tank today. If they're coming down, you wait. Roth conversions work the same way. You're choosing when to pay the tax, not whether to pay it.
If you convert while you're in the 12% or 22% bracket and would otherwise pull that money out later at 24% or higher, the conversion can make a lot of sense. But if you're in your peak earning years at 32% or 35%, and you expect to be in the 22% bracket in retirement, converting now could mean paying more tax than you ever would have. That's not a tax strategy. That's prepaying the IRS at a premium.
For 2026, a married couple filing jointly stays in the 12% bracket up to $100,800 of taxable income, in the 22% bracket up to $211,400, and in the 24% bracket up to $403,550. Those lines are your guardrails. A good conversion plan often fills up a lower bracket on purpose without spilling into the next one.
The other side of the coin is that nobody knows exactly what tax rates will be 20 years from now. The current rates were made permanent under the One Big Beautiful Bill, but "permanent" in Washington only lasts until Congress changes its mind, right? That's why the goal isn't to predict the future perfectly. It's to spread your risk by having some money in pre-tax accounts, some in Roth accounts, and some in taxable accounts, so you have options no matter what happens.
The RMD Snowball
Here's where "later" can sneak up on you. Once you reach a certain age, the IRS stops letting you decide when to take money out of your pre-tax accounts. Those are required minimum distributions, or RMDs. They start at 73 if you were born between 1951 and 1959, and at 75 if you were born in 1960 or later.
The math is simple. You take last year's December 31 balance and divide it by an IRS life-expectancy number. At 75, that number is 24.6. So a hypothetical couple with $2 million in IRAs at 75 would have to withdraw about $81,300 that year, whether they need the money or not. And the required percentage keeps climbing: about 3.8% at 73, about 4.9% at 80, and about 8.2% at 90.
Picture a snowball rolling downhill. You spend decades contributing, the account grows, and then RMDs force it out in bigger and bigger pieces. Stack that on top of Social Security, a pension, or investment income, and many retirees end up in a higher bracket in their late 70s and 80s than they were in their 60s. Those same RMDs can also trigger the tax torpedo and IRMAA, which we'll get to next.
That's why the years between retirement and RMDs are often the sweet spot for conversions. Your paycheck has stopped, RMDs haven't started, and your income may be the lowest it'll be for the rest of your life. Converting some money then can shrink the snowball before it gets too big. And because Roth IRAs don't have RMDs for the original owner, that money can keep growing on your timeline, not the IRS's.
It doesn't stop with you, either. Most adult children who inherit a traditional IRA have to empty it within 10 years. If you had already started RMDs, they also have to take withdrawals each year along the way. That often lands during their own peak earning years. A Roth conversion today could mean a smaller tax bill for your kids later.
Hidden Cost #1: The Social Security Tax Torpedo
This one catches a lot of retirees off guard. How much of your Social Security gets taxed depends on something called provisional income: your other income, plus tax-exempt interest, plus half of your Social Security benefit. For married couples filing jointly, up to 50% of your benefit becomes taxable once provisional income passes $32,000, and up to 85% once it passes $44,000. For single filers, the lines are $25,000 and $34,000. Those thresholds have never been adjusted for inflation.
Here's the torpedo. Once you're in that zone, every extra dollar of income, including a Roth conversion, gets taxed itself and can also pull up to 85 cents of your Social Security into taxable income along with it. Someone in the 22% bracket can end up paying an effective 40.7% on those dollars, and someone in the 12% bracket can pay 22.2%. You think you're in the 22% bracket, but you're really paying closer to 40%. Ouch, right?
This is why timing matters so much. Converting before you start collecting Social Security can sidestep the torpedo entirely.
Hidden Cost #2: Medicare's IRMAA Surcharge
Medicare looks at your income from two years ago to set your Part B and Part D premiums. In 2026, married couples filing jointly with income above $218,000, or single filers above $109,000, pay an extra charge called IRMAA.
It isn't a small percentage on the amount you go over. It works in tiers, like a staircase. Go $1 over the first line and each person on Medicare pays about $1,148 more per year. The higher tiers cost more.
Because of that two-year lookback, a conversion you do at 63 can raise your Medicare premiums at 65. It's easy to forget, and it adds up quickly.
Hidden Cost #3: The New Senior Deduction
The One Big Beautiful Bill added a $6,000 deduction for each person 65 and older for tax years 2025 through 2028. It starts shrinking once income passes $150,000 for married couples or $75,000 for single filers. For a couple who both qualify, it's gone completely at $250,000.
A large conversion in one year can erase a deduction you otherwise would have kept. Spreading conversions over several smaller years can protect it.
Hidden Cost #4: The Pro-Rata Rule
If you don't want to convert a big chunk all at once, doing it gradually is common. This is especially true for higher earners whose income is too high to deduct IRA contributions or contribute to a Roth directly. They make a nondeductible IRA contribution and then convert it, which is often called a "backdoor Roth."
There's a trap here. Say you already have $800,000 in a traditional IRA, and you add the 2026 maximum of $7,500 as a nondeductible contribution. You didn't get a deduction for it, so you'd assume you can convert that $7,500 tax-free, right?
Not quite. The IRS treats all of your traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs as one big account, using their balances on December 31. Your after-tax money is only $7,500 of $807,500, or less than 1%. So about 99% of that conversion is taxable.
One way around this is to roll your pre-tax IRA money into your employer's 401(k), if the plan accepts roll-ins. Then your IRA holds only the new after-tax contribution, and the conversion can be close to tax-free. Any growth before you convert is still taxable.
A Few More Things People Forget
- There's no undo button. Conversions done since 2018 can't be reversed. If the market drops or your income comes in higher than expected, you still owe the tax.
- Each conversion has its own five-year clock. If you're under 59½ and withdraw converted money within five years, you may owe a 10% penalty.
- Required minimum distributions come first. Once RMDs start, you have to take that year's required amount before converting, and it can't go into the Roth.
- The survivor squeeze. When one spouse passes away, the survivor usually files single the following year. The tax brackets, IRMAA thresholds, and senior deduction lines all get cut roughly in half, while the income often doesn't drop by nearly as much. Converting while both spouses are alive can soften that.
- State taxes count too. Your state may want its share of the conversion.
So When Does It Make Sense?
Roth conversions aren't good or bad. They're a tool. The question isn't "Should I convert?" but "How much, and in which years?" Often the sweet spot is the gap between retiring and starting Social Security or RMDs, when income is lower and you can fill up a lower bracket on purpose.
The goal isn't to pay the least tax this year. It's to pay the least tax over your lifetime, and ideally your kids' too. That takes a plan, a projection, and a conversation with your planner and CPA before you click "convert." And always remember, in the world of investing and tax planning, it's not what you make, it's what you keep.
Here's to planning well and living fully.
—Tyler